Picture this: You’re scrolling through Instagram between doctor’s appointments after your Orlando car accident, and there they are again – those ubiquitous ads from Florida personal injury law firms promising quick settlements and fast cash. Maybe you’ve seen their billboards towering over I-4, or their commercials interrupting your favorite shows. They make everything sound so easy, so fast. But here’s what keeps me up at night as a Orlando personal injury lawyer: many accident victims don’t realize how these mass-marketing law firms actually handle cases behind the scenes – or how their assembly-line approach could affect your future.
What I’m about to share isn’t just theory. I’ve spent years handling serious accident cases throughout Central Florida, watching with growing concern as more and more injured people unknowingly walk into a system that wasn’t designed to maximize their case value.
The Best Florida Personal Injury Lawyers vs High-Volume Practices: What Extensive Research Shows
Law Professor Nora Freeman Engstrom, of Stanford Law School, conducted an extensive, multi-year study of high-volume personal injury law firms, which she termed ‘settlement mills.’ Her research results were clear, and the evidence is shocking to most people who aren’t familiar with how these firms operate. Before you make a decision that could affect your future, you critically need to understand how high-volume law firms really handle cases.
As an Orlando car accident attorney, I was extremely frustrated when I recently discovered a Reddit discussion where some random non-lawyer recommended that a car accident injury victim call one of the larger firms with lots of billboards. Picture me screaming into the void.
The personal injury lawyers behind these ads often operate what legal scholars have dubbed “settlement mills” — high-volume law firms that process personal injury claims with assembly-line efficiency. While these firms may seem like a tempting option, especially when you’re dealing with the stress of an injury, extensively documented academic research suggests they could be leaving serious money on the table for those with moderate to severe injuries. Let’s dive into why you might want to think twice before dialing that catchy jingle if you’ve suffered a major accident.
What Exactly is a Settlement Mill?
To understand the potential pitfalls facing Orlando accident victims, we first need to define our terms.
These firms have several distinguishing characteristics that set them apart from traditional law practices:
- High Volume: They handle an enormous caseload, often 300–400 cases per attorney annually. This is several times the number a conventional Florida personal injury lawyer might handle.
2. Aggressive Advertising: They invest heavily in marketing, especially television ads. It’s not uncommon for these firms to spend over a million dollars annually on advertising. Therefore, if they have billboards or television ads, the research showed that would make it almost impossible, financially, for the law firm to survive without handling a high volume of cases.
3. Rare Court Appearances: They rarely, if ever, take cases to trial. Some firms in Engstrom’s study hadn’t taken a single case to trial in years.
4. Quick Resolution: They resolve cases rapidly, usually within 2–8 months. This is significantly faster than the typical timeline for a personal injury case.
5. Heavy Use of Paralegals: They delegate much of the case work to non-attorneys, including crucial tasks like settlement negotiations.
6. Settlement Incentives: They often employ quota systems or other incentives to encourage quick settlements. In other words, the lawyers working for these high volume injury firms have major incentives to churn through all cases as quickly as possible. For example, each lawyer might receive a larger bonus at the end of the year if they have total recovered fees greater than certain pre-set monetary fee goals, which are generally impossible to meet without quick and lower value settlements per case. The law simply isn’t that predictable, as far as timing, unless you are willing to settle for less.
7. Tiered Fee Structures: Unlike most personal injury firms that charge a flat percentage, settlement mills often use tiered fees that increase if a lawsuit is filed.
In essence, these high volume personal injury firms have industrialized personal injury law, turning it into a streamlined, routinized process — more akin to fast food than a gourmet meal.
The Settlement Mill Business Model
Settlement mills operate on a high-volume, quick-turnover model that’s radically different from traditional law practices. They invest heavily in advertising to attract a constant stream of new clients, then process these cases as efficiently as possible. The goal is to settle fast, collect the fee, and move on to the next case.
This approach is made possible by the nature of most Central Florida car accident cases. The majority involve relatively minor injuries and straightforward liability. For these small cases, settlement mills can often secure a quick payout without much fuss. They’ve developed standardized procedures and cultivated relationships with insurance adjusters to grease the wheels of the settlement process.
One personal injury attorney interviewed by Engstrom described the process like this: “It’s a cookie-cutter. It’s routine. You call and they offer you $500 and you ask for $2,000, and then you go to $1,000. If you get $1,200, you do it, but it’s just boom, boom, boom like that.”
Why Settlement Mills Can Work for Minor Injuries In Florida
If you’ve suffered only minor injuries in an accident, a settlement mill might not be a bad option. Here’s why:
1. Quick resolution: You could have a check in hand within a few months, rather than the year or more it might take with a traditional firm.
2. Guaranteed compensation: These firms rarely take cases they can’t settle, so you’re likely to get something. In fact, Engstrom found that some settlement mills settle over 90% of their cases.
3. Accessibility: They’ll take cases many traditional firms would turn down as too small. This opens up legal representation to a segment of the population that might otherwise go unserved.
4. Efficiency: For simple cases, their streamlined processes can be beneficial. You’re not paying for unnecessary work.
For a straightforward whiplash case that might net you a few thousand dollars, the efficiency of a settlement mill could be appealing. You might not get top dollar, but you’ll get something, and you’ll get it fast.
That being said, if you were injured in an auto accident, you should not decide what the best Orlando personal injury lawyers and insurance companies might consider a minor (versus moderate to severe) injury. The fact is, in the early days after any car or truck accident, many people have no idea how serious their injuries really are. Months later, when they realize that their physical therapy isn’t working, and their doctor tells them that they need surgery, they often simultaneously realize that hiring the high volume billboard guys and gals was an extremely costly mistake. (Alternatively, some never realize how much money they left on the table.)
The Best Florida Accident Lawyer for Those With Serious Injuries: Research-Based Guidelines
However, if you’ve suffered moderate to severe injuries, the settlement mill approach could cost you dearly. Here’s a deeper look at why:
1. Lower settlements for serious cases: Settlement mills often leave money on the table in more valuable cases. They’re set up to process cases quickly, not to maximize value through careful preparation and negotiation. One attorney in Engstrom’s study admitted, “I am personally aware of many cases I think [were] settled for far less” than they were worth.
2. Lack of individualized attention: With such high caseloads, attorneys at these firms simply can’t give complex cases the time and attention they deserve. Engstrom found that some settlement mill attorneys handle 200 to 300 open files at any given time. Compare this to conventional firms, where attorneys typically juggle 70 cases at most.
3. Inadequate investigation and preparation: Settlement mills often skimp on crucial steps like interviewing witnesses, consulting experts, or thoroughly documenting damages. One attorney confessed, “There was never any investigation done of the claim… The only investigation that was ever done was whether or not someone had insurance.”
This drives me bananas!
Moderate to serious injury cases require extensive investigation, and fighting for evidence from the defendant during any lawsuit, to have any chance of having a truly high value case.
4. Reluctance to litigate: These firms are built on settling, not suing. If the insurance company plays hardball, they’re less likely to file a lawsuit and push back. Engstrom found that while conventional personal injury firms file lawsuits in 30–50% of their cases, some settlement mills file suits less than 5% of the time.
5. Misaligned financial incentives: Many settlement mills use quota systems or offer bonuses for quick settlements. This can incentivize attorneys to settle your case prematurely. One firm in the study offered a monthly “shark” award to the attorney who generated the most fees.
6. Limited client interaction: At some settlement mills, clients rarely meet their attorney face-to-face. One lawyer admitted, “Very often, the first time I saw the client was when they came in to sign their settlement check.”
7. Pressure to accept settlements: Because of their business model, settlement mills have a strong interest in getting clients to accept offers quickly. This can lead to undue pressure on clients to settle for less than their case is worth.
8. Advertising budget doesn’t equal better outcomes: Some might assume that firms with massive advertising budgets must be the most successful at winning big settlements. However, Engstrom’s research suggests otherwise. In fact, the ability to advertise heavily often comes at the expense of individualized client attention and case preparation. One attorney in the study explained, “As advertising costs got higher, it made more sense to use a case manager rather than an attorney. Take the money you save from utilizing case managers and plow it into advertising.” This approach might increase the firm’s overall revenue, but the evidence clearly proved that high volume, heavy advertising approach did not translate to better outcomes for individual clients, especially those with serious injuries. Moreover, Engstrom found that conventional firms often got better settlement offers for comparable cases, despite spending far less on advertising. The reality is that insurance companies are more concerned with an attorney’s reputation for thorough case preparation and willingness to go to trial than they are with how often they see the attorney’s face on TV. As one insurance adjuster admitted, it can be “advantageous” to have a high-volume advertiser as an opponent because they know these firms are less likely to push hard on big cases.
9. Size doesn’t always matter, but volume does: It’s critical to understand that the issues associated with settlement mills aren’t exclusive to large firms. Many smaller firms also operate on a high-volume model. The real concern is the caseload per attorney, not necessarily the size of the firm. An attorney juggling hundreds of cases simply can’t give each one the attention it deserves, regardless of whether they work for a large or small firm. That said, firms with extensive billboard and television advertising campaigns — which tend to be larger — are almost invariably high-volume operations. Engstrom’s research revealed that these firms couldn’t sustain their massive advertising budgets without processing a high volume of cases quickly. This creates a cycle where high advertising expenses necessitate high volume, which in turn requires shortcuts in case handling. When seeking representation, focus less on the firm’s size and more on the individual attention your case will receive.
Evidence from Engstrom’s Study: Biggest Definitely Wasn’t The Best
Engstrom’s research provides compelling evidence that settlement mills often underperform on serious injury cases. Here are some key findings:
1. Comparative settlement amounts: Former settlement mill attorneys reported that when they left to join conventional firms, they started getting significantly better offers for comparable cases. One attorney estimated that cases he had settled for $10,000-$20,000 at the settlement mill would have been worth much more at a conventional firm.
2. Anecdotes from former attorneys: Multiple attorneys told Engstrom they felt pressure to settle cases quickly rather than maximize value. One said, “I had a hard time turning everyone around really quick and taking very little money.”
3. Insurance company perspectives: Insurers actually like dealing with settlement mills. One adjuster was quoted as saying it’s “advantageous” to have a particular settlement mill as an opponent. Why? Because they know these firms won’t push hard on big cases.
4. Lack of litigation threat: Settlement mills rarely file lawsuits. One firm in the study filed suits in only about 5% of cases, compared to conventional firms that typically file suit in 30–50% of cases. This removes a crucial source of leverage in negotiations.
5. Quick turnover: Most settlement mills resolve cases within 2–8 months. While speed can be good, it often comes at the cost of thorough case development.
6. Delegation to non-attorneys: Many settlement mills have paralegals handling negotiations. While this can work for simple cases, complex injuries require the expertise of an experienced attorney.
7. Going rates: Settlement mills often rely on standardized “going rates” for injuries rather than individualized assessment. One attorney described it as “a grid” where certain injuries automatically equate to certain settlement amounts.
Choosing the Best Orlando Injury & Accident Lawyer: Research-Based Guidelines
If you’ve suffered a significant injury, here’s what you should look for in an attorney:
1. Track record of litigation: You want someone who insurers know will take them to court if necessary.
2. Individualized attention: Your attorney should have the time and resources to thoroughly investigate and prepare your specific case. They should be able to articulate a unique strategy for your situation.
3. Willingness to go to trial: While most cases settle, you want an attorney ready and able to take your case before a jury if that’s what it takes to get fair compensation. Ask about their trial philosophy.
4. No quotas or settlement incentives: Your attorney’s financial interests should align with getting you the best possible outcome, not the quickest. Ask about their compensation structure.
5. Expertise in serious injury cases: Look for an attorney with a track record of handling cases similar to yours. They should be able to discuss the unique challenges your type of injury presents.
6. Resources to go the distance: Serious injury cases can be expensive to litigate. Make sure your attorney has the financial resources to see your case through, including hiring necessary experts.
7. Clear communication: Your attorney should be able to explain complex legal concepts in terms you can understand. They should also be responsive to your questions and concerns.
8. Respected by peers: Look for attorneys who are active in professional organizations and have received recognition from their peers.
Conclusion: Biggest Does Not Mean Best
Settlement mills have their place in the legal ecosystem. For minor injuries, they can provide accessible, efficient resolution. But if you’ve suffered a moderate to severe injury, the evidence suggests you’d be better served by a more traditional law firm.
The decision of who to hire as your Orlando car accident lawyer or personal injury attorney is one of the most important choices you’ll make in your case. It can literally be a million-dollar decision. So do your research. Ask tough questions about an attorney’s approach. Don’t be swayed by flashy advertising or promises of quick cash.
Remember, the Orlando personal injury law firm with the catchiest jingle isn’t necessarily the one who will get you the best result. Your case deserves individual attention, thorough preparation, and the best Orlando injury & accident lawyer ready to go to the mat for you. Don’t settle for less just because it’s quick and easy. Your future may depend on it.
In the end, the choice is yours. But armed with this information, you’re now better equipped to make an informed decision about your legal representation. Your health and financial future are too important to leave to chance or to sacrifice for the sake of speed and convenience. Choose wisely, and may your path to recovery be smooth and just.
What Makes the Best Personal Injury Lawyers Different?
The decision of who to hire as your attorney could literally be a hundreds of thousands or million-dollar choice. The best Orlando accident lawyers aren’t necessarily the ones you see advertised most often. Instead, the best Orlando injury and accident lawyers share several key characteristics:
- Selective case acceptance
- Individual attention to each case
- Attorney time needed to properly investigate & litigate
- Willingness to go to trial
- Experience with all phases of litigation, including:
- the motions often needed to secure critical evidence discovery & admission (or omission)
- the best jurisdiction & venue for your case
- the best jury instructions
- the best taking & defending depositions of defense witnesses
- the best deciding on which witnesses to call, and what other evidence to present
- the best helping you prep for your own deposition
- the best litigation & pre-suit procedural posturing & compliance
- the best expert witnesses
- the best legal research when needed, regarding countless legal issues that arise during every lawsuit
- the best arguments to the insurance adjusters, defense attorneys, mediators, and sometimes judges and juries
- the best research & analysis of your case value based on prior case precedent, published settlements and verdicts, and existing laws
- and many other complex litigation issues
- Focus on maximizing case value
- Direct attorney involvement & careful supervision of staff working on all cases
- Experienced in the highest value cases, for those with the most serious & catastrophic injuries
- Individual attention to your case
- Thorough case preparation
- Willingness to go to trial
- Track record of maximizing case value
A Better Approach for Orlando Accident Victims
At Tina Willis Law Injury & Accident Lawyers, we take a dramatically different approach. From our Orlando office, we handle cases throughout Florida, developing unique and aggressive strategies for every client after lengthy discussions with them. With our low volume, maximum value case strategy, our small, highly experienced & award-winning team has recovered multi-millions for our clients. We routinely handle everything from lawsuits involving moderate injuries to Florida’s most catastrophic injury and wrongful death cases.
Want to learn more about how we maximize case value through our focused, selective approach? We invite you to call (407) 803-2139, or visit our contact page for a free consultation about your specific situation.
Related Posts
Why You Should Never Represent Yourself
More About High Volume Settlement Mills (more actual data from this same study)